cafe #1: boxcar social
coffee
cafes
by Nathan Lardizabal | 1/23/2026
officially starting my toronto coffee blog with cafe #1: boxcar social!
---
location: 499 Richmond St W, Toronto, ON M5V 0P4
what i got: karimikui AA washed pourover (kenya), with a salted chocolate chip cookie ðĪŠ
price: $12.15 ($6.75 before tax for the pourover)
---
the cafe is located inside of this place called waterworks food hall, which has a variety of multi-cultural food vendors. i've been to another boxcar social around college/spadina years ago, but i wasn't really into coffee back then.
vibe/ambience - 6.5/10
the vibe of waterworks is aightttt it's not your standard cafe vibe i feel, but it has its own little charm to it! it's giving corporate LOL however boxcar social itself feels very bar-like and modern -- which is cool but to me it's not really giving peaceful/relaxing/homey/warm. every cafe is going to give a different ambience for sure, but i'm the one grading here ðĪ·ââïļ what can i say LOL

presentation - 8/10
they presented the coffee in the pour-over service tray style, which i love! however i feel like whenever cafes do this, it's not as much coffee LOL but that's cool


price - 8.5/10
they don't have a set price, so they list it as mp (market price). i had to ask what mp meant LOL ð $6.75 for a pourover isn't bad! i feel like some other cafes tend to price their pourovers in the $10+ range, so this was great :)

coffee quality - 8/10
the coffee was great! super clean, fresh and pure ðŪâðĻ honestly idek what AA, washed, SL-2B and all that mean and idek if i can taste it LOOL but hey it was some good coffee!
i put it at an 8/10 because there wasn't anything craaazy with it, just some good quality kape ð but yeah hopefully my taste buds get more sophisticated so i can go more in-depth with how the coffee tastes and all that. idek what type of coffee i rly like ðĪ·ââïļ but that's a journey i shall be taking with this series :)
final score - 7.7/10
i've thought long about how to weigh these criteria, and i've placed coffee quality as the highest weight at 45%! vibe is also important to me because i really want to relax, and the environment should be warm and inviting for me ð presentation and price aren't as important so i'm keeping them at 15% each.
coffee quality: 8.0 Ã 0.45 = 3.6
vibe: 6.5 Ã 0.25 = 1.625
presentation: 8.0 Ã 0.15 = 1.2
price: 8.5 Ã 0.15 = 1.275
final score: 7.7 / 10 hope you enjoyed! see you at the next cafe review :)
(ps. i'll try to set up some sort of newsletter system soon)